Old Country Store North Cohocton

4 Old Country Stores Around Rochester

These businesses are not just country gift shops with farm-house-themed decor. When you walk into one of these old country stores, you’re stepping back in time with aisles of old-fashioned toys, knickknacks, and candies. The nostalgia is joyful!

Our Old Country Stores

  1. Vidler’s 5 and 10
  2. Marilla Country Store
  3. Genesee Country Village
  4. Olde Country Store and More
Vidlers 5 and 10 East Aurora
Vidlers toys
Vidlers lunchboxes
Vidlers 5-and-10 gnomes
Vidler’s 5 and 10 in East Aurora

1. Vidler’s 5 and 10 Variety Store

East Aurora, built in 1930

Vidler’s is nostalgic and fun. You could spend hours wandering around the store’s four connected buildings and still won’t see everything!

You’ll appreciate their entertaining and quirky commercials on YouTube if you’re looking for more reasons to go!

Day Trips Around Rochester New York

Please help fuel my quest!

People often ask, “Do you get into places for free?” The answer is no. I rarely mention Day Trips Around Rochester, NY, while out-and-about. I want the same experience you would have. I create and share content because I love to and believe you’ll find it valuable, not because I’ve been paid to promote it. If you’d like to fuel my quest for new and exciting places to share, I’d appreciate anything from a cup of coffee to a full gas tank. Thank you!

Marilla Country Store Autumn store front
Marilla Country Store Christmas decor
Marilla Country Store candy selection
Marilla Country Store fun toys
Marilla Country Store

2. Marilla Country Store

Marilla, built in 1851

The Marilla Country Store has been in continuous operation ever since. Always a store, the historic building features original plank floors, countertops, and vintage gaslights.

A museum is open to visitors and features an extensive collection of antique merchandise and old store equipment and original advertising, stories, and more from the store’s history.

This one-of-a-kind store, one of the oldest businesses in Western New York, offers an incredible selection of fresh bulk foods, candies, gifts, and décor.

Genesee Country Village Museum mercantile
Genesee Country Village Museum mercantile
Genesee Country Village pottery
Genesee Country Village maple syrup
Genesee Country Village molds
Genesee Country Village confectionery
GCV Confectionery

3. Genesee Country Village Mercantile, Confectionery, and Pub

Mumford, established in 1976

Enjoy 19th Century life in “the village that might have been.” There are several shops throughout the village. Flint Hill Gift Shop and Village Mercantile offer historic toys, goods, crafts, and village memorabilia. D.B. Munger & Co. Confectionery (open Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays) sells historic sweet treats. And the Freight House Pub sells the museum’s 19th-century inspired beer. 

As a history museum, they pride themselves in offering products authentic to the 1800s, with many made right in the village. The stores are open when the museum is.

Things to do around Rochester NY: Old Country Store
Olde Country Store and More 1894 interior
Old Country Store table
Olde Country Store and More North Cohocton
Olde Country Store and More – 1894

4. The Olde Country Store and More – 1894

North Cohocton, built in 1873

There is a vast bulk candy selection (350 varieties!), with candy bars and old-fashioned candies that you’ve not seen on modern store shelves in a long time.

You’ll also find locally-produced honey, maple syrup, mustard, pancake mixes, granola, jams and jellies, and cheeses.

If you’re heading down to the Naples Festival in late September, make The Olde Country Store, Joseph’s Wayside Market, and Jerome’s U-Pick Grapes part of your family’s tradition.

Open March through the end of December, they do close for the winter.

Genesee Country Village & Museum

Genesee Country Village is the largest living history museum in New York State, and the third-largest in the United States.

Read more

Explore East Aurora, NY

From Vidler’s to the Aurora Theatre to the Roycroft Arts & Crafts movement, the early 1900s are alive and well on Main Street in East Aurora.

Read more

19 Rochester-Area Chocolatiers

Many of our fine Rochester-area chocolatiers are 3rd- and 4th-generation descendants using traditional family recipes with modern twists.

Read more

Apple Everything! Rochester’s best ciders, fry cakes, fritters, pies, and more

Come mid-September, we begin to crave all things apple. Apple cider. Apple cider donuts. Apple fritters. Apple pie. And warm fry cakes.

Read more

🍁 Maple Weekends: 10 Sweet Sugar Shacks Near Rochester

During Maple Weekends March 19-20 and 26-27, 2022, producers open their sugar shacks to celebrate the process of turning sap into syrup.

Read more

100+ Places to Shop Local, Rochester!

You don’t have to wait for Small Business Saturday to shop local! We have some incredibly talented individuals throughout the Rochester area.

Read more

What do you love most about old country stores?

Please share your thoughts and stories with us in the comments. Your insight and experience are invaluable!

Debi Bower, Day Trips Around Rochester NY

Author Debi Bower is the Founder and Creative Director for Day Trips Around Rochester, NY.

16K Shares

4 thoughts on “4 Old Country Stores Around Rochester”

  1. Olde Country Store, in North Cohocton, is a fantastic store. Have been there many times and loved it every time. So much candy to choose from and other great items!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *